More agencies are turning to lifecycle cost analysis because it identifies the most costeffective long term alternative for highway construction maintenance and rehabilitation. Life cycle cost analysis lcca is performed by transportation agencies in the design phase of transportation projects in order to be able to implement more economical strategies, to support decision processes in pavement type selection flexible or rigid. This interim technical bulletin recommends procedures for conducting life cycle cost analysis lcca of pavements, provides detailed procedures to determine work zone user costs, and introduces a probabilistic approach to account for the uncertainty associated with lcca inputs. Chapter 4 lifecycle cost analysis guide for pavement. Trbs national cooperative highway research program nchrp synthesis 494. Life cycle cost analysis provides an approach for computing the cost of a product or its serviceability. Lifecycle cost analysis lcca is an analytical framework to assess the most economically prudent investment from a set of alternatives.
A life cycle cost analysis of rigid pavements authors. A life cycle cost analysis is conducted to identify the best value, i. The development of lcca tool enables examination of various design options to determine which pavement type is the most cost effective over the total life cycle of the. For example, an lcca may be conducted to help decide whether a rigid pavement design or a flexible pavement design should be used for a particular. I am pleased to provide the annual report on pavement life cycle cost analysis, as required under minn. Pdf life cycle cost assessment of electric vehicles. Life cycle cost analysis of asphalt and concrete pavements. The vice provost for land and buildings convened a team of staff from departments within land and buildings, along. Integration of life cycle cost analysis lcca and life cycle assessment lca to select pavement alternative is a solution to address economic and environmental issues simultaneously. Fhwa promotes lifecycle cost analysis lcca as an engineering economic analysis tool that allows transportation officials to quantify the differential costs of alternative investment options for a given project. Pavement design and materials is a practical reference for both students and practicing engineers that explores all the aspects of pavement engineering, including materials, analysis, design, evaluation, and economic analysis. Pavement lifecycle cost studies using actual cost data.
Indot design manual standards, and a survey of experts. To help shas and other agencies conduct such an analysis, this report provides best practices for properly determining inputs for use in their lcca procedures and calculating the life cycle costs of pavement alternatives. An appropriate and nonbiased method for life cycle cost analysis is articulated by the federal highway administration fhwa in demonstration project no. This interim technical bulletin recommends procedures for conducting lifecycle cost analysis lcca of pavements, provides detailed procedures to determine work zone user costs, and introduces a probabilistic approach to account for the uncertainty associated with lcca inputs. Life cycle cost analysis of municipal pavements in southern and.
Pavement life cycle cost studies using actual cost data a synthesis introduction the performance and economy of highway pavements is a matter of critical importance to governmental agencies, highway engineers, paving contractors and others involved in the highway industry. Pavement design processes pavement design spreadsheets. The lcca should be performed early in the design process. Life cycle costing analysis using the mechanisticempirical pavement design. Life cycle cost analysis for indot pavement design procedures. Lifecycle cost analysis lcca whole building design guide. Chapter 4 lifecycle cost analysis guide for pavementtype. Many building owners apply the principles of life cycle cost analysis in decisions they. Authors geoffrey lamptey, muhammad ahmad, samuel labi and kumares sinha 8.
A guide on the basic principles of lifecycle cost analysis lcca. Pavement division, hng40 office of engineering federal highway administration 400 7. Pdf pavement analysis and design download full pdf book. While most of current methods related to sustainable design of pavements consider environmental parameters as economic factors i. There is usually not a single design that meets the design criteria but a number of alternative designs.
I am pleased to provide the annual report on pavement lifecycle cost analysis, as required under minn. The determination of lifecycle costs of alternative pavement types is an important part of a rational means for decision making. Officials in all states indicated that lcca helped ensure that the agency selected the pavement that was most costeffective over the long term, but states specific lcca. The one project on which a lcca was not completed was for a design build. Integrating lifecycle assessment and lifecycle cost. Lifecycle cost analysis is not an engineering tool for determining how long a pavement design or rehabilitation alternative will last or how well it will perform. Life cycle cost analysis is an assessment method for estimating the performance of materials and services considering their impact on environment, from extraction of raw materials to the endoflife disposalrecycling stage. The development of lcca tool enables examination of various design options to determine which pavement type is the most cost effective over the total lifecycle of the. If you need to print pages from this book, we recommend downloading it as a pdf. Life cycle cost analysis lcca hilaris publishing srl. Pavexpress allows users to design pavement structures according to aashto 9398 design formulae, as well as to conduct additional analysis and comparison of projects, including life cycle cost analysis.
Unfortunately, this book cant be printed from the openbook. They also estimated an economical cost analysis, which showed us that the life cycle cost of concrete pavement is about twenty to twenty five percent. An appropriate and nonbiased method for lifecycle cost analysis is articulated by the federal highway administration fhwa in demonstration project no. Life cycle costs analysis of reclaimed asphalt pavement rap. Life cycle cost analysis for pavement type selection scdot. Working from literature, historical data and interviews, the lcca technique is described and an overview of the road and street system in iceland is presented.
It is used to compare of each design alternatives over its life alternative, considering all parameters of cost and benefits. Information is presented on how life cycle can be used to select the alternative that is least expensive over time. Thirteen of the 16 state transportation agencies gao contacted used lifecycle cost analysis lcca to select the pavement type e. Pavement analysis and design download pavement analysis and design ebook pdf or read online books in pdf, epub, and mobi format. The pavexpress suite of pavement design tools includes an lcca module based on fhwas realcost lcca tool. Rps also ranks alternative designs according to their total life cycle costs 15. Information is presented on how lifecycle can be used to select the alternative that is least expensive over time. Auburn university national center for asphalt technology perpetual pavement demonstration workshop. Ncat report 1903 best practices for determining life cycle. Life cycle cost analysis can be performed on large and small buildings or on isolated building systems. Life cycle cost analysis, pavement design, pavement. Pavexpress allows users to design pavement structures according to aashto 9398 design formulae, as well as to conduct additional analysis and comparison of.
Lifecycle cost analysis life cycle cost analysis design. Many agencies are turning to lifecycle cost analysis lcca as a means of evaluating the longterm economic viability of pavement designs. Joint transportation research program, indiana department of transportation and purdue university, west lafayette, indiana, 2005. Life cycle cost analysis lcca is performed by transportation agencies in the design phase of transportation.
Life cycle cost analysis is an assessment method for estimating the performance of materials and services considering their impact on environment, from extraction of raw materials to the endof life disposalrecycling stage. An evaluation of life cycle cost analysis of airport pavement. Reclaimed asphalt pavement rap has received wide application in asphalt pavement construction and maintenance and it has shown cost effectiveness over virgin hot mix asphalt hma. That is why eupave decided to draft this guide on lcca life cycle cost. The typical cost of a crumb rubber modified crm mix is 1. Historically, numerous techniques have been applied by a multitude of jurisdictions dealing with roadway pavements. Ontario municipalities typically consist of superpave asphalt mix designs. These results can be used to assist in the selection of pavement marking materials for roadways based on aadt and needed service life. Lifecycle cost analysis an overview sciencedirect topics. This study evaluates life cycle cost of flexible road pavement design alternatives in a typical niger delta urban town to determine the most. The subject is also important to the citizen taxpayers, who want the. Click download or read online button to get life cycle cost and economic analysis book now.
This report describes a life cycle cost analysis lcca for road pavements and evaluates its impact on pavement type choice. Life cycle cost analysis of portland cement concrete. The basis for this pavement marking life cycle analysis is the retroreflectivity of the material which is measured in mcdluxm2. The determination of lifecycle costs of alternative pavement types is an important. It takes into account all costs of acquiring, owning, and disposing of a building or building system. Street sw, washington, dc 20590 federal highway administration 400 7th street, sw washington, dc 20590. This site is like a library, use search box in the widget to get ebook that you want.
This synthesis will be of interest to pavement designers, maintenance engineers, and other concerned with selection of pavement designs and pavement rehabilitation alternatives. The lcca methodology developed here is tested on a hypothetical. Work zoneis defined in the highway capacity manual hcm as an area of a. Idot mechanistic pavement design and lifecycle cost analysis. Adjustments to pavement lifecycle cost analysis procedures. Rob harrison, steve waalkes, and william james wilde september 1999 the university of texas at austin center for transportation research project summary report 1739s 1 what we did. The primary purpose of the comprehensive pavement design manual cpdm is to provide designers with a singlesource compilation of current department policy and guidance pertaining to pavement designs for projects falling under the jurisdiction of the nys department of transportation. Lifecycle cost analysis for management of highway assets documents the state of the practice of lifecycle cost analysis lcca and riskbased analysis into state highway agencies asset management plans for pavements and bridges on the national highway system.
Pdf life cycle cost analysis for pavement type selection. The one project on which a lcca was not completed was for a designbuild. The basis for this pavement marking life cycle research is the retroreflectivity of the material which is measured in mcdluxm 2. The quality of the results of an lcca depends on economic inputs and the quality of the engineers. Lcca is a subset of benefit cost analysis bca, an economic analysis tool that compares. They also estimated an economical cost analysis, which showed us that the life cycle cost of concrete pavement is about twenty to twenty five percent lower than bituminous pavement. A life cycle cost analysis of rigid pavements project summary report 1739s project 01739. However, the benefits of using crm are many, and therefore, a life cycle cost analysis lcca should be performed. Pdf evaluation of pavement life cycle cost analysis. Lifecycle cost analysis the pennsylvania experience. It may be used as a tool to help select the most appropriate design for the particular project.
Click download or read online button to pavement analysis and design book pdf for free now. Then, through simulation, output cost is expressed as ranges of values, also with probabilities of occurrence. This spreadsheet will perform the calculations required by chapter 54 of the bde manual to determine a design thickness and conduct a lifecycle cost analysis. There is usually not a single design that meets the design criteria but a number of alternative designs that can be considered as viable solutions. Lifecycle cost analysis for management of highway assets. A life cycle cost analysis lcca is an analysis methodology that enable engineers, designers, and decision makers to better understand the economic impacts of infrastructure decisions over time along with the opportunities that exist to reduce impacts. The determination of life cycle costs of alternative pavement types is an important. Reclaimed asphalt pavement rap has received wide application in asphalt pavement construction and maintenance and it has shown costeffectiveness over virgin hot mix asphalt hma. Estimates of life cycle costs should become more accurate as pavement management procedures begin providing historical cost, serviceability, and performance data. In 2015, a lcca was conducted for 32 ofthe 33 construction projects in the reconditioning, resurfacing and road repair funding categories. Rps also ranks alternative designs according to their total lifecycle costs 15. Life cycle cost analysis lcca is an economic evaluation technique that determines the total cost of owning and operating a facility over period of time.
This report describes the development of a new life cycle cost analysis methodology for portland cement concrete pavements one that considers all aspects of pavement design, construction, maintenance, and user impacts throughout the analysis period. The procedure herein was derived largely from the federal highway administration technical bulletin, life cycle cost analysis in pavement design, discussion with various stakeholders and both asphalt and. Pavement lifecycle cost studies using actual cost data a synthesis introduction the performance and economy of highway pavements is a matter of critical importance to governmental agencies, highway engineers, paving contractors and others involved in the highway industry. Life cycle cost analysis for pavement design epic training. Download pdf pavement analysis and design free online new. Life cycle cost analysis of municipal pavements in southern and eastern.
Life cycle cost analysis lcca is a method for assessing the total cost of facility ownership. A life cycle cost analysis of rigid pavements project. Pdf the cost of road construction consists of design expenses, material extraction. The cost of road construction consists of design expenses, material extraction, construction.
Life cycle cost analysis and perpetual pavements dr. Life cycle cost analysis lcca is an analytical framework to assess the most economically prudent investment from a set of alternatives. Based on costbenefit ratio, these results can be used to assist in the selection of pavement marking materials for roadways based on adt and needed service life. Life cycle cost and economic analysis download ebook pdf. Integration of lifecycle cost analysis lcca and lifecycle assessment lca to select pavement alternative is a solution to address economic and environmental issues simultaneously. It predicts pavement performance using stateoftheart performance. Lack of longterm field performance data for newer asphalt and concrete pavement. For infrastructure, major total cost over the lifetime of these assets is encountered after construction, i. Lifecycle cost analysis in pavement design interim technical bulletin september 1998. Life cycle cost analysis of asphalt and concrete pavements final.
1380 1327 99 442 850 829 533 1153 89 1472 309 23 1007 177 880 34 787 736 521 436 1380 1364 1522 1449 1182 230 217 41 1253 519 640 758 1488 903 364 914 878 1440 770 515 485 1106 1229